Rochester, NY
Categories:
Tactics Used |
|
---|---|
Auto Seizure | ✓ |
Buyer Arrests | ✓ |
Cameras | ✓ |
Community Service | ✓ |
Employment Loss | ✓ |
Identity Disclosure | ✓ |
IT Based Tactics | ✓ |
John School | ✓ |
Letters | ✓ |
License Suspension | ✓ |
Neighborhood Action | ✓ |
Public Education | ✓ |
Reverse Stings | ✓ |
SOAP Orders | ✓ |
Web Stings | ✓ |
Rochester is a city of approximately 200,000 residents, located east of Buffalo in Monroe County, New York. The city has experienced chronic and well-documented issues related to prostitution and sex trafficking for many decades. A recent example includes a case in which a Rochester man pled guilty to sex trafficking by coercion, admitting to using the victim’s addiction to heroin to coerce her to engage in commercial sex acts with men in the Rochester area. The man was a registered sex offender who committed this offense while on probation in Monroe County. This particular investigation commenced in January 2019 after Rochester Police Department officers responded to a residence in the City of Rochester for the report of a fatal overdose involving a minor victim. The owner of the apartment found the minor deceased on his living room floor and called 911. He told officers he brought the minor victim back to his residence to engage in commercial sex acts with her. The investigation determined the man was sex trafficking the minor victim until shortly before her death. The prosecution was the product of an investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office. In addition to sex trafficking, the local commercial sex market has also attracted at least two serial killers who specifically targeted women selling sex in Rochester.
To address such serious crimes, the Rochester Police Department has adopted several tactics that target the underlying demand for commercial sex. The RPD began arresting sex buyers in reverse stings in 1988, if not before. That same year, the city established a “john school” type of program, making it among the first cities in the country to do so and preceding San Francisco‘s First Offender Prostitution Program (FOPP) by seven years. While Rochester’s program preceded the FOPP, it appears to have been short-lived, while the FOPP operated for 20 years and went on to be replicated or adapted in over 100 cities on three continents.
Loss of employment is another consequence for sex buyers that has occurred in the city. In February 2022, a former professor at the Rochester Institute of Technology was sentenced to 15 years in prison after a 17-year-old’s fatal overdose led to him being convicted of sex trafficking by coercion. In 2019 the victim was found dead on a living room floor after being brought into the home to engage in commercial sex acts. A surviving trafficking victim had testified that the former professor has also sexually abused her.
Community residents have also mobilized to identify and deter sex buyers. The Lyell Avenue Area 230 Group, for example, has coordinated with police to arrest male sex buyers on occasion. In several instances, residents reportedly complained to the police and provided tips about prostitution activity occurring in the area. In addition, the group operated a “Dear John” website that was updated periodically with pictures of individuals arrested for attempting to purchase sex in Rochester.
Key Partners
- Rochester Police Department
- Monroe County District Attorney’s Office
- Lyell Avenue Area 230 Group
- Paper Bag Ladies of Rochester
Key Sources
National Assessment Survey and Interview
Street-Level Reverse Stings:
- “Hundred Arrested in Rochester Prostitution Crackdown”, Albany Times Union, July 29 1991.
- “Prostitution Crackdown Fills Jail”, Watertown Daily Times, July 29 1991.
- “Rochester Fails in Crackdown on Prostitution”, Buffalo News, July 29 1991.
- “Men Convicted for Soliciting Prostitute”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, July 6 2009.
- “Prostitution Crackdown on Lyell Ave. Gets a Boost”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, July 6 2009.
- https://13wham.com/15-arrested-for-patronizing-a-prostitute-in-rochester (2017)
- https://www.rochesterfirst.com/15-arrested-for-patronizing-prostitute-in-rochester (2017)
Loss of Employment, Identity Disclosure:
- https://www.miamiherald.com/ (2022)
Neighborhood Action:
- Lyell Ave. Area 230 Group
- “Men Convicted for Soliciting Prostitutes”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, July 6 2009.
- “‘Dear John’ Campaign Focuses on Lyell Ave. Neighborhood”, TWCN-TV 9, July 7 2009.
- “VIDEO: Cleaning Up Prostitution, Part One”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, November 22 2011.
- “VIDEO: Cleaning Up Prostitution, Part Two”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, November 23 2011.
Cameras:
- “Cams to Keep Eye on Jones Square”, TWCN-TV 9, June 21 2006.
- “Rochester Police Make High Tech Investment”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, October 24 2006.
Public Education:
- http://paperbagladies.org/media/Dear%20John_%20Billboards%20Slat.pdf
- https://www.cook-communications.com/blog/keeping-out-the-johns (2016)
Sex Trafficking and Child Sexual Exploitation in the Area:
- “Two Accused of Abducting Woman for Prostitution; Victim Contacts Police in Massachusetts”, Buffalo News, June 15 2006.
- “Teen Prostituted for Drugs”, TWCN-TV 9, September 19 2007.
- “Woman Denies Pimping Teen”, TWCN-TV 9, October 9 2007.
- “Woman Gets 12 Years for Sex Charges”, TWCN-TV 9, May 27 2008.
- “Sex Trafficking Lurks in Offbeat Rochester Lairs”, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, April 28 2012.
- “Rochester Man Charged with Running Sex Trafficking Operation Involving a Minor Victim”, U.S. Federal News Service, August 7 2012.
- “Rochester Man and Woman Charged in Sex Trafficking Case”, U.S. Federal News Service, December 15 2012.
- “Rochester Couple Face Sex Trafficking Charges of a Minor”, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, December 16 2012.
- “Rochester Mother’s Vigilance Helps Police Make Arrests”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, April 4 2013.
- “Two Rochester Men Indicted in Sex Trafficking Case”, Press Release, U.S. State Attorney’s Office for the Western District of New York, July 9 2013.
- “Man Accused of Plotting to Slay Witness”, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, November 1 2013.
- “Rochester Sisters Admit to Sex Trafficking Minors”, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, January 9 2014.
- “Sex Trafficker Conviction Shows Changing Legal Landscape”, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, February 13 2014.
- “Brighton Man Sentenced for Sex Trafficking”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, February 21 2014.
- “Rochester Man Pleads Guilty to Sex Trafficking”, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, March 19 2014.
- “Two Men Accused of Sex Trafficking Minors,” Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, September 25 2015.
- “Rochester Man Charged with Sex Trafficking a Minor,” Press Release, U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of New York, October 14 2015.
- “Man Pleads Guilty to Sex Trafficking,” Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, February 16 2016.
- https://www.stl.news/new-york-news-rochester-andre-l-barnes-federal-jury-convicts-rochester-man-of-sex-trafficking (2018)
- https://geneseesun.com/peter-kiwitt-of-rochester-pleads-guilty-to-sex-trafficking-by-force/ (2021)
- https://www.justice.gov/federal-grand-jury-charges-rochester-man-sex-trafficking-enticement-and-possession (2021)
- https://13wham.com/rochester-man-going-to-prison-for-sex-trafficking-minor (2022)
- https://www.rochesterfirst.com/local-tattoo-shop-offering-free-removals-for-sex-trafficking-victims/ (2023)
- https://13wham.com/amp/news/local/sex-trafficking-prostitution-kidnapping-suspects-in-court-victim-attacked-hotel-camera-punched-pulled-hair-assault-rescued-rochester-new-york-henrietta (2023)
Documented Violence Against Individuals Engaged in Prostitution in the Area:
- “Third Slaying of Hooker Probed”, Albany Knickerbocker News, March 25 1988.
- “Rochester Prostitutes Warned They May Be Murder Targets”, Watertown Daily Times, November 17 1989.
- “Killer Stalks Easy Targets”, Watertown Daily Times, November 29 1989.
- “Rochester Police Have Suspect in One of 13 Unsolved Slayings”, Albany Times Union, November 30 1989.
- “N.Y. Serial Killer Suspected; Rochester, N.Y.”, USA TODAY, December 4 1989.
- “Furor over Slayings Grows; Rochester, N.Y.”, USA TODAY, December 9 1989.
- “In Rochester, Serial Killings of Prostitutes”, Newsday, December 10 1989.
- “New York Group Seeks Help for Women in Rochester”, USA TODAY, December 11 1989.
- “Rochester Mourns Slain Women”, Watertown Daily Times, December 11 1989.
- “‘Red-Light’ District Business Down in Rochester”, USA TODAY, December 13 1989.
- “Paroled Killer Held in Deaths of Rochester Women; Food Service Worker Pleads Innocent to 8 Murder Counts”, Buffalo News, January 5 1990.
- “Man Held in Serial Killings”, St. Louis Post-Dispatch, January 6 1990.
- “Suspect Was Friendly, Weird; Rochester, N.Y.”, USA TODAY, January 6 1990.
- “Some Prostitutes Back in Business; Rochester, N.Y.”, USA Today, January 8 1990.
- “Shawcross Link Eyed to ’89 Ohio Murders; Most of Victims Are Prostitutes, Investigators Say”, Watertown Daily Times, January 11 1990.
- “A City Stumbles on a Suspect in a String of Women’s Deaths”, Philadelphia Inquirer, January 14 1990.
- “TV News Director Subpoenaed in Serial Killing Case; Rochester”, USA TODAY, February 22 1990.
- “Police Sought Prostitute to Identify Alleged Killer”, Watertown Daily Times, June 5 1990.
- “Judge Releases Confessions by Shawcross Detailing Sexual Atrocities, Serial Killings”, Watertown Daily Times, September 21 1990.
- https://www.nytimes.com/nyregion/rochester-slaying-suspect-is-called-kind-but-violent (1990)
- “Syracuse and Rochester Police Probe Slayings”, Watertown Daily Times, October 25 1991.
- “Rochester Police Seek Strangling-Murder Links”, Watertown Daily Times, May 20 1992.
- “Woman’s Slaying Similar to Others in Rochester”, Watertown Daily Times, September 5 1992.
- “Body Raises Serial Killer Fears; Rochester Area Police Refuse to Say Deaths of Four Prostitutes Are Linked”, Watertown Daily Times, October 28 1992.
- “State Briefs; Another Body Discovered Near Rochester Highway”, Watertown Daily Times, November 4 1992.
- “Rochester Streetwalker Still Strolls Beat Despite Series of Killings”, Watertown Daily Times, November 19 1992.
- “Police Feel Most Recent Prostitute Murder Suggests Killer Has Become More Daring”, Watertown Daily Times, December 10 1992.
- “Prospect of a Second Serial Killer Has White-Collar City Frightened”, Watertown Daily Times, December 14 1992.
- “Shawcross’ Heart of Darkness”, Watertown Daily Times, March 7 1993.
- “Haunting Similarities; Cops Draw Parallel with Killer Shawcross”, Newsday, June 30 1993.
- “Painful Mystery Endures in Rochester”, Newsday, July 1 1993.
- “Evidence Challenged in 1973 Murder Case”, Albany Times Union, March 1 1998.
- “A Conviction Ruled Unjust Leads to a Redemption”, New York Times, May 29 1998.
- “Woman’s Years in Prison Make Freedom Rough”, Los Angeles Times, December 19 1999.
- “Freed Man Faces New Trial 25 Years after Original Conviction”, Lubbock Avalanche-Journal, January 23 2000.
- “Witness in 1973 Murder Says Police Terrorized Him into Lying”, Associated Press Archive, January 28 2000.
- “Man Acquitted in Retrial of 1973 Murder”, Associated Press Archive, February 3 2000.
- “Manlius Skeleton Is Rochester Prostitute; Woman Was Killed by a Massena Man Paroled for Another Slaying, Police Say”, Syracuse Post-Standard, February 25 2002.
- “Police Work Gives a Name, and a Suspect”, Syracuse Post-Standard, February 26 2002.
- “Statement Allowed in 1986 Murder Case, Defense Said Man Accused of Killing Prostitute Had Invoked Right to Remain Silent”, Syracuse Post-Standard, September 13 2002.
- “Man Guilty of Murder in 1986 Death, Jury Takes 90 Minutes to Convict in Case Involving Remains Found in Manlius”, Syracuse Post-Standard, October 9 2002.
- “Police Release More Info on Rapes”, TWCN-TV 9, August 24 2005.
- “Victims of Unsolved Serial Killer Case Remembered”, TWCN-TV 9, November 12 2008.
- “The Genesee River Killer”, Rochester Examiner, November 25 2009.
- “Rochester Murder Remains Unsolved”, Rochester Examiner, January 15 2010.
- “Police Identify Woman Found Dead on Lyell Ave”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, January 10 2011.
- “Arrest in Murder of Woman Found in Garbage Tote”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, January 21 2011.
- “Police Search for 2 Men Who Dragged Prostitute in Road with Car”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, February 28 2011.
- “Matthew Townsend Found Guilty of Murder”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, February 22 2012.
- “Michael Chess Convicted for Serial Rapes”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, October 24 2013.
- https://13wham.com/amp/news/local/sex-trafficking-prostitution-kidnapping-suspects-in-court-victim-attacked-hotel-camera-punched-pulled-hair-assault-rescued-rochester-new-york-henrietta (2023)
Background on Prostitution in the Area:
- “GRANET Busts Alleged Rochester Prostitution Ring”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, January 24 2012.
- “Rochester Police Call Prostitution Sting a Success”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, September 21 2012.
- “Police and Lyell Ave Neighbors Don’t Consider Prostitution a Victimless Crime”, TWCN-TV 9, April 19 2013.
- “RPD Busts 20 in Prostitution Sting”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, April 19 2013.
- “Woman Works to Help Prostitutes”, TWCN-TV 9, April 29 2013.
- “Rochester City Court to Feature Human Trafficking Unit”, CBS/WROC-TV 8, October 2 2013.
State | New York |
Type | City |
Population | 211328 |
Location |
Comments are closed.